Musings at the intersection of business and life

Are incubators the latest business fad?

Starting a Business
June 12, 2011 by Kathleen Allen

 I’m beginning to think that everyone believes that incubators hold the secret to entrepreneurial success. When you look at all the incubators that have launched in the past few years, you would certainly get that impression. Some highly respected people have launched such programs as yCombinator, TechStars, Plug and Play, and IdeaLab, to name just a few. Their goal? To claim the next great startup, whether it be an Internet company, an energy company, or a retail play.

The competition has gotten so intense that some like Peter Thiel, Paypal co-founder and hedge fund manager, have decided it’s time to go after people under the age of 20. His “20 Under 20” program awards up to $100,000 to 20 people under the age of 20 who are willing to pursue a startup that leverages science and technology instead of enrolling in a university. He points to successful entrepreneurs who either never attended college or dropped out such as Elon Musk (PayPal, SpaceX, Tesla Motors, etc.). Thiel’s intent is to hand select very high potential individuals, perhaps from very prestigious universities, and get them to leave to launch their ventures. This approach is not much different from pro teams drafting top athletes out of college. Some people mourn the lost education while others say optimistically that they can always go back to school, but when will another opportunity like this come along? Actually, I agree with this thinking to a point. If you have a business idea that is really a killer idea and the time to launch is now, then I say go for it. Today, it’s about lifelong learning and even if you do have a college degree, the learning never stops.

But back to my original thought about incubators popping up everywhere. I just returned from Sioux Falls, South Dakota where my nonprofit, N2TEC Institute, just completed its third technology accelerator program. For three years my partner, Tim Stearns, and I  have been working with technology startups in an effort to enhance the wealth creation process in South Dakota. South Dakota????? Actually, Sioux Falls, SD has been touted by Forbes magazine as the best small city for business in the U.S. Unlike most incubators, we focus on the last mile in the launch process, giving a selected group of businesses an intense week of challenging their business models and helping them get traction. This accelerator is about economic development, fostering new technology startups from within the state rather than resorting to the traditional approach of stealing companies from other states. If you want to read about this year’s startups, click here.
To be successful, incubators must have a purpose beyond making money. That’s because most incubators have a tough time even covering their costs. In the case of N2TEC’s Technology Accelerator, our goal is to make sure that the rural areas of the U.S. are tapped into entrepreneurship. It’s not enough for the two coasts to be successful—we want all of America, especially “fly-over” country, to enjoy the benefits of entrepreneurship.
 
So are startup incubators the latest fad? Probably, but any programs that encourage entrepreneurship are bound to be a benefit to society, so I say, bring ‘em on!

Related tags: 20 Under 20, Idealab, incubator, Peter Thiel, Plug and Play, TechStars, yCombinator

Leave a Comment